Sunday, September 15, 2019
Henry Higgins Bullies Eliza Doolittle
Pygmalion is a well-known play written by George Bernard Shaw in 1912. In mythology, Pygmalion was a sculptor who fell in love with one of his statues. In the play, Professor Henry Higgins represents the ââ¬Ësculptorââ¬â¢ who falls in love with Eliza Doolittle, his creation. He makes a bet with another linguist that he can pass her off as a proper lady and begins to teach her how to speak proper English. Due to Higginsââ¬â¢ impersonal nature, he treats Eliza badly causing her to leave once she wins his bet.After finding her at his mother's house, he learns that she intends to work for herself and possibly marry an upper class twit she met there previously. He leaves upset, and she comes back to him because she realizes that even though he doesn't show his emotions, he does care for her. Firstly, some of Higginsââ¬â¢ behaviours prove that he does bully Eliza. This can be shown by Higgins treating her like dirt and telling her what to do all the time, like he has control ov er her.For example, when Eliza is convinced that Higgins is a policeman (when in fact he isnââ¬â¢t) in Act 1, she believes that he will charge her for prostitution after she calls a stranger ââ¬ËCaptain. ââ¬â¢ She panics with ââ¬Ëmuch distressââ¬â¢ and ââ¬Ëstruggles with her emotionââ¬â¢. Irritated by her whines and wails, Higgins loses his temper and says ââ¬Å"Woman: cease this detestable boohooing instantly. â⬠The use of the word ââ¬Ëwomanââ¬â¢ suggests that Higgins is impersonal and doesnââ¬â¢t even bother to ask what her name is.Also, by saying ââ¬Ëceaseââ¬â¢ we can see that he is using imperative language and this emphasises the fact that he tries to control her. In addition, we know that Higgins is very angry because of the stage direction, ââ¬Ëexplosivelyââ¬â¢. Eliza reacts with ââ¬Ëfeeble defianceââ¬â¢ especially as nobody has spoken to her like that before. Furthermore, Higgins says ââ¬Å"Donââ¬â¢t sit there crooni ng like a bilious pigeon. â⬠Again, Higgins uses imperative language in his attempts to control Eliza. He also uses natural imagery to portray Eliza as an unclean, sick animal you can find on any of the streets of London.Although in the play, Higginsââ¬â¢ character is portrayed to be mean and unsociable as we can see when he says to his mother ââ¬Å"I know I have no small talk; but people donââ¬â¢t mind. â⬠This quotation is evidence that he is quite impersonal, not just to Eliza, but to everyone. For example, when he meets Mrs Eynsford Hill, he says that heââ¬â¢s ââ¬Å"delighted,â⬠sarcastically and bluntly and is uncomfortable, also shown by the stage direction, ââ¬Ëglumlyââ¬â¢ and ââ¬Ëbacks awayââ¬â¢. However, Shaw also shows some of Higginsââ¬â¢ softer sides. For instance, in Act 4 Eliza is furious withHiggins because she feels like sheââ¬â¢s just been treated as an experiment and not like a person. Here she provokes Higgins by shoutin g and throwing insults at him so he finally tells her ââ¬Å"It is you who have hit me. You have wounded me to the heart. â⬠This suggests that Higgins never realised he hurt Eliza or treated her wrongly. However it also shows that heââ¬â¢s upset with Eliza for failing to realise that deep down he really does care about her feelings. However, in a sense Higgins is irresponsible for deciding to allow a young vulnerable woman stay in his house without knowing anything about her.The main reason he takes her in is for the money that he can win in his bet with Pickering. Mrs Pearce has to frequently warn Higgins that if he takes Eliza in as a pupil, she will be his responsibility and also that he must ââ¬Ëlook ahead a little. ââ¬â¢ This is because Mrs Pearce is concerned that once Eliza has learnt to speak properly, she will be used to the luxuries of Higginsââ¬â¢ house and wont have any money, clothes or a suitable home to live in once itââ¬â¢s time to move out. Higg ins however takes no notice of Mrs Pearce and says ââ¬Å"When Iââ¬â¢ve done with her, we can throw her back into the gutter. From this we can tell that he is impersonal and doesnââ¬â¢t call Eliza by her own name, it also implies that he doesnââ¬â¢t care about her at first and just thinks of her as an experiment. Towards the end of the play after the garden party, Higgins says fervently ââ¬Å"Thank God itââ¬â¢s over! â⬠Eliza reacts by ââ¬Ëflinching violentlyââ¬â¢ but ââ¬Ëthey take no notice of herââ¬â¢. From the stage direction ââ¬Ëferventlyââ¬â¢ we can tell that Higgins is speaking with spirit and confidence which emphasises how little he cares about Elizaââ¬â¢s journey to become a lady in a flower shop which hurts her deeply as we can tell from the stage directions.Another way in which we can prove Higgins doesnââ¬â¢t bully Eliza is through the fact that heââ¬â¢s very generous and liberal with her. An example of this is when Eliza meet s him in his house, the day after their first encounter. Higgins offers Eliza life changing lessons, new clothes and shelter but at first she ungratefully refuses them. Also, Higgins is undoubtedly busy man with not much time to spare because of his phonetics experiments and studies. Nevertheless, he decides to take Eliza into his own home and sacrifices months and months of his time to assist Eliza in her ââ¬Ëlady-in-a-flower-shopââ¬â¢ dream.In conclusion, Higginsââ¬â¢ character is impersonal, unsociable and he definitely has the tendency to cause an argument at times. Higgins calls Eliza some nasty names in Pygmalion such as ââ¬Ëbaggageââ¬â¢ and even ââ¬Ësquashed cabbage leafââ¬â¢ however it isnââ¬â¢t meant in a malicious way. This is because Higgins doesnââ¬â¢t really know how to act normally around other people and has a lack of social skills and he even admits it himself. Higgins never physically bullied Eliza, heââ¬â¢s big hearted, used to banter, but finds it difficult to express his emotions and occasionally forgets to think before he speaks.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.